Bieber, 28, wore a white tank top with baggy jeans and kitten heels sandals, while Jenner, 29, was dressed in sandals and a short-sleeved gray maxi dress. Smiling mom-of-one Bieber held onto an iced coffee as she made her way into the store, while model Jenner had a large brown tote bag on her shoulder.

“If Justin had his way, they’d be together 24/7 and trying for another baby,” the source shares of the dad of two, who shares Silas, 10, and Phineas, 4, with Biel.